& Suite 110C By continuing to use our site, you are agreeing to our Cookies Policy Oakland, CA 94612 Contact Us today for a Free Consultation With her. At her doctors suggestion, Nathalie Carpenter used an endometrial receptivity analysis ahead of two in vitro fertilization cycles: One worked, but the other failed. and A.P., the couple said they were shocked in March 2019 when they gave birth and realized that the children werent of Asian descent, as they are. From extended hours to accommodate your busy schedule, to comfortable waiting areas and convenient communication, everything that we do at each of our locations is focused on putting patients' needs first, including equipping our lab with the latest advances in reproductive medicine. Click here. They no longer trust anyone, and their guard is always up. Teen migrant claims Border Patrol agent sexually assaulted her, sparking federal investigation, Use a bit of common sense: A gender-reveal party stunt ends with a car erupting in flames. More than 4,000 eggs and embryos were lost at the University Hospitals Fertility Clinic in Cleveland, affecting hundreds of patients. The three women were each awarded about $2 million to $3 million, while the couple was awarded $7.2 million. Standing beside our clients, weve been able to provide a platform for other families to step forward and tell their stories. It was indescribable. You may be entitled to a settlement by filing a suit and we can help. patients are faced with a growing list of costly add-ons. For one such test, some say more robust research is needed to support its effectiveness. A Los Angeles clinic has been accused in a new lawsuit of a fertility treatment mix-up that left a New York woman pregnant with twin boys unrelated to her or to each other, according to the Sacramento Bee. The woman and her husband had been trying to conceive unsuccessfully since they were married in 2012, so they traveled from their home in Queens, New York, to CHA Fertility Center in Los Angeles to consult with their doctors in January 2018. Full-time. in New York. In court papers, attorneys said the embryos and eggs lost represented the only chance for some of the patients to conceive children. If youre a current patient, please email your care team ([emailprotected]). These tanks specifically, theyre not regulated any better than kitchen appliances or farm tools, he said. Incredible team and world-class operation! The couple said that CHA allegedly implanted another couple's embryo in her womb. You can also try calling from an alternate wireless service provider or landline. It can also include diseases that licensed physicians recognize as causing infertility conditions. Employers are prohibited from discriminating against women who take leave for pregnancy. My husband and I struggled with unknown fertility issues before our first consult. Taking off work for fertility treatments is a common legal issue. Doctors who inserted their own sperm into their patientswithout their consentviolated their patients. The study was led by researchers from Shady Grove Fertility, which has more than 40 clinics across the United States. View job. San Francisco, CA 94109 There are different IVF laws by state. add-ons that are scientifically unproven, said Pamela Mahoney Tsigdinos, a patient advocate and the author of Silent Sorority., While the test is certified and regulated by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, it is not approved by the Food and Drug Administration. No government agency directly oversees assisted reproduction in the United States, and the only federal law that touches the process primarily regulates the manner in which clinics can advertise their pregnancy success rates. When Rhian Thomas, a 39-year-old television producer in New York, was preparing for her first embryo transfer at the Columbia University Fertility Center, she told Dr. Forman, the centers medical and laboratory director, that she wanted an E.R.A., even though he was skeptical. About a decade ago, Anni and Ashot Manukyan of Glendale, Calif., entrusted their embryos to a fertility clinic in Los Angeles that promised its in vitro fertilization technique would lead to a baby. What Anni and Ashot discovered, much to their horror, was that their son had been stolen from them when he was still an embryo and implanted into a stranger that later became his birth mother, claims a lawsuit filed Wednesday in Los Angeles County Superior Court. DNA testing eventually proved that the twins, both boys, werent related to them or each other, the lawsuit said. cycles, each years apart.. In other words, Anni was injected against her will with the sperm and egg of a man and woman who are complete strangers to her, the filing recounts. Monday Friday: 7:30AM-4PM, 905 San Ramon Valley Blvd Still, federal law currently excludes sexual orientation as a protected class. She also wanted to know if she may have passed on such a condition to her own child. A fertility clinic in Cleveland, Ohio, where thousands of frozen embryos and eggs were allegedly lost in a storage tank failure is being investigated by the Ohio Department of Health, according to the Washington Post [4]. 3 days ago. has reached maturity as a technology and were approaching the limits of its efficacy, said Dr. Andrea Vidali, a reproductive immunologist and repeat miscarriage specialist in New York. 1519 Robert C. Blakes Sr Dr, 1st Floor BOOK A CONSULT 143933), who maintained an Ob Gyn practice in Manhattan. Without common-sense regulation, the Wild West nature of the multibillion-dollar fertility industry leaves the door open for instances of fertility fraud and other fertility clinic disasters, like those recently experienced in Cleveland and San Francisco. Law Practice, Attorney Tuesday: Closed The lawsuit is the most recent in a string of complaints alleging negligence by fertility clinics across the U.S. In other words, many different parties could be held liable since a single fertility treatment can often affect the contributions of many different healthcare professionals. The lawsuit further states that medical providers at the clinic, when they said they were implanting in the womans uterus one of the embryos she had created with her husband, transferred at least one embryo of a stranger to Anni.". At least four more proposed class action lawsuits have been filed against US Fertility in the wake of the 2020 data breach detailed on this page. I have been hurt by these experiences in ways that haunt me every day, Anni Manukyan said during the news conference. Please provide a valid Zip Code or City and choose a category, Please select a city from the list and choose a category. So you start to pull back. The test, called an endometrial receptivity analysis, takes a biopsy of the interior lining of the uterus. This situation has upended my life and my family and the damage it is doing and the emotional scars that it is creating may never heal. Our law firm handles cases throughout the entire United States including Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin and Wyoming. This study makes it easier to explain why we do not recommend this test when patients have read positive testimonials online, he said. Spring Fertility 100% strongly recommend 7 Reviews Rated 9.8 9.8 Show 10 more This clinic has 8 offices Visit clinic website Danville 905 San Ramon Valley Blvd Danville, CA 94526 510-470-1835 New York 114 W 41st Street, 2nd Floor New York, NY 10036 415-964-5618 Show 6 more 250 patient reviews Filter by patient information Rating Strongly Recommends This was the period when inseminations became more common, but before at-home DNA testing was on the horizon. In other words, the test does not improve chances of achieving an ongoing pregnancy in first-time patients, according to the findings. Life on hold: How the pandemic has stalled fertility treatments, Decades after her insemination, she says tests revealed the doctor was the father: Its a severe violation, U.S. birthrate falls to its lowest level in decades in wake of pandemic. Tuesday, Thursday: Closed, 550 Lakeside Drive This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Well share resources, events, news and more! The cases allege US Fertility fell short of its duties under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability ActHIPAAby exposing confidential, personally identifiable patient information, including dates of birth, demographic details, Social Security numbers, medical histories, insurance information, photo IDs, employer information and other data related to fertility treatments. Jurors found that the storage tank maker, Chart Industries, knew about a defect in its equipment that prevented accurate temperature monitoring but neglected to recall the units or warn the public about the problem. Regulations have hardly evolved since, he said. Spring Fertility is a private fertility clinic located in California, USA. Amy Zeman and Dena Sharp were co-lead trial counsel for the plaintiffs who received the jury award. Daughter Learned Her Biological Father Was Her Mothers Fertility Doctor by Taking 23andMe Home DNA Test Kit; Law Firm Renews Call for Crackdown to End Wild West Days of U.S. test, said Dr. Peter Klatsky, a founder of Spring Fertility, which has clinics in California, New York and Vancouver. SPRING NEW YORK Now. He was eventually convicted of lying to prosecutors and obstructing justice when questioned about complaints alleging he used his own sperm rather than sperm from anonymous donors. Jurors held Chart 90 percent responsible and Pacific Fertility Center 10 percent responsible for the failure. Infertility treatments are Assisted Reproductive Technology, or ART. However, it wasnt until 2014 that 23andMe home DNA kits began to reveal Clines secret. A man was swept over the largest waterfall at Niagara Falls, police say. Monday Friday: At the Disney California Adventure Food and Wine Festival, you will find a palate-dazzling smorgasbord of cuisines and cocktails in which to indulge. Ty began working at LegalMatch in November 2021. The lead plaintiff in the lawsuit against Pacific Fertility Center and Chart had her eggs retrieved and frozen in October 2016 and was paying to have them stored at the center, according to court . They said two embryos were supposed to be used and the third was discarded. The 29-page lawsuit in Maryland federal court says hackers were able to access US Fertility's cloud-based systems from August 12 through September 14, 2020, and viewed patients' names, dates of birth, addresses, Social Security numbers, driver's licenses and state ID numbers, passport numbers, medical treatment and diagnosis information, medical Spring Fertility was founded by leading physicians with the goal of redefining the reproductive and fertility patient experience to improve comfort, communication and care while advancing scientific excellence. Law, Government The couple said they spent more than $100,000 on treatment and other expenses at CHA Fertility Center, according to a lawsuit. You say when. The lawsuit pins blame for the data breach on US Fertilitys carelessness and inadequate data security, claiming fertility clinic patients have, as a result, lost all sense of privacy. Many proposed class members have suffered irreparable harm and now face an increased risk of identity theft and fraud due to the defendants inadequate and laxed [sic] approach to data security, the complaint alleges. During the trial, the women and the couple described their pain from the loss. The U.S. fertility industry has fewer regulations than barber shops or nail salons. In closing arguments during the San Francisco trial, a lawyer for Chart blamed the fertility center for the tank failure. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated. I dont care. 2022 Peiffer Wolf Carr Kane Conway & Wise, LLP. Aware that Greenbergs son, unfortunately, passed away at an early age, she wanted to know if she may have inherited a concerning medical condition. In 1983, Bianca Voss wanted to be a mother and she visited the offices of Dr. Greenberg for fertility services. Even with their son now in their care, they say they have been irreparably harmed by the ordeal. Some of the more commonly encountered legal issues in connection with fertility treatment laws include: Suppose you have received infertility treatments and are experiencing any of the above circumstances. Ms. Holmes is on trial for fraud charges.). transfer failed, and they are looking for answers.. Danville, CA 94526, Monday, Wednesday, Friday: 8AM-5PM Moreover, weve been able to provide a pathway to recovery for their losses. New to ClassAction.org? Theres no system of warnings or disclosures or any other measures to track reproductive facilities or hold the specialists accountable.. New York, NY. Copyright 1999-2023 LegalMatch. The case mounted by the couple is the second in the past 10 days targeting the CHA Fertility Center in Los Angeles, as well as several of its leaders. I mean. Save this computer Anni and Ashot Manukyan were married in 2007, according to the legal filing. Were aware that some AT&T wireless customers are unable to reach our main telephone line. to those who did not, and researchers found no difference between the two groups. cycles, each years apart. Messages left for Charts attorney and Pacific Fertility werent immediately returned Thursday. He believes add-ons like the E.R.A. New York prohibits paid arrangements, and experts advise that surrogacy contracts are not enforceable in court. At the same clinic in early 2020, she had also experienced "gut-wrenching pain" while undergoing an egg retrieval procedure. Also, the facility is clean, modern and they take great strides to provide patients with privacy and to make sure that a tailored program and calendar is provided. Steven Santana. For example, such a lawsuit might involve medical malpractice because a doctor violated health standards for IVF procedures. and egg freezing) performed in the United States in 2019, according to preliminary data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, with nearly 78,000 patients giving birth. The United States is in the midst of uncovering thousands of fertility fraud cases, in which IVF/Ob Gyn doctors have abused their position of trust and authority by secretly inserting their own sperm when carrying out fertility treatments. 1998 - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved. A second suit, also entered against the University Hospitals center, was filed by a Pennsylvania couple who allegedly spent 8 years trying to conceive and were in the process of transferring the embryo to the woman. Other accidents and mishaps have plagued fertility clinics around the country in recent years. On Wednesday, the Manukyans came forward with Wolf as the parents of one of the boys born to Y.Z. Valid for self-pay patients only. An attorney for CHA Fertility did not return a request for comment on Wednesday. Monday Friday: 7:30AM-4PM, 3001367 West Broadway Redwood City, CA 94063, 80 Grand Avenue Wednesday Friday: 7:30AM4PM, 570 Price Avenue A fertility clinic in Los Angeles is facing multiple lawsuits alleging that it swapped . In court testimony, plaintiffs described how the trauma of losing eggs made them feel helpless. During the 70s and 80s, fertility clinic doctor Donald Cline fathered more than 50 children by using his own sperm on unwitting patients, according to The Atlantic [5]. San Francisco, CA 94105, Entrance off Beale Street, orange elevators, Monday: 7:30AM4PM Your proactive ovarian reserve checkup- 15 minutes, $149*, 16 people have successfully posted their cases, 5 people have successfully posted their cases, 10 people have successfully posted their cases, 6 people have successfully posted their cases, 20 people have successfully posted their cases, 7 people have successfully posted their cases, 9 people have successfully posted their cases, Can't find your category? "Anni and Ashot do not know whose embryos were actually transferred to Anni on that day. The company, which was acquired by Vitrolife in July, said that 25 other studies 16 internal and nine independent supported use of the test. Ty is a native of Lake of the Ozarks, Missouri, and currently resides in Kansas City. The roots and possible solutions to the worsening situation at such facilities are addressed inthe new Peiffer Wolf issue briefer, The Fertility Center Regulation Crisis in the U.S.: Peiffer Wolf is nationally recognized for representing victims of fertility clinic misconduct and fertility doctor misconduct, including destruction or loss of eggs and embryos. Whether it's now or later. Fox noted the freezer units that store eggs and embryos were developed decades ago to hold livestock semen for breeding. The husband and wife say they still dont know whose embryos were transferred to Anni not leading to successful pregnancies when at least one of theirs wound up going to someone else. Spring is here. Law, Insurance Some unscrupulous fertility doctors thought that they could get away with it without being caught. When the couple discovered the error this spring, they said it took an agonizing legal fight the most excruciating period of their lives to reclaim the child. They cry every day. According to the suit, proposed class members privacy rights were disregarded by US Fertilitys reckless and/or negligent failure to properly safeguard their data, as well as timely disclose the incident and the material fact that it did not have strong enough computer systems to protect patient information. Y.Z. Spring Fertility is redefining the fertility experience. Between 1999 and 2013, gestational surrogacy where the surrogate has no biological link to the baby resulted in the birth of 18,400 infants, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. In 2019, the firm spearheaded the Peiffer Wolf push for national legislation to rein in the abuses of IVF and fertility clinics. An embryologist shows an ovocyte after it was inseminated as part of an assisted reproduction procedure. Defendants misconduct robbed Anni of the ability to carry her child throughout his fetal development. This is an important and emotional ending for our clients who have been through so much pain and hardship since the 2018 tank failure, said Amy Zeman, who served as co-lead counsel for the plaintiffs at trial along with attorney Dena Sharp. MAJOR FERTILITY CENTER LAWSUITSUNDERSCORE WILD WEST NATURE OF UNREGULATED INDUSTRY WITH U.S. Easily apply. It paints a stark portrait of the human cost of the alleged mishandling of the genetic material. are a result of an industry focused on troubleshooting I.V.F. LOS ANGELES - A male same-sex couple is suing a Pasadena in-vitro fertilization clinic, alleging their hopes of having a son were stymied when a female embryo was wrongly . The jury spoke loudly and unequivocally today, and their clear determination of Charts responsibility for the defective tank will have significant ramifications for future cases.". Then their son was born to a stranger across the country, lawsuit claims. 24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events. US Fertility faces a class action over a month-long 2020 data breach. We recognize that your history, your situation, and your goals are unique, and we believe your treatment plan should be too. NATIONAL WAVE OF FERTILITY FRAUD: CASE FILED AGAINST CA DOCTOR SEEN AS FIRST OF HUNDREDS TO BE EXPOSED BY HOME DNA TESTS. The hurting needs to stop and responsibility must be taken," he said. Learn more about egg freezing with our comprehensive Egg Freezing Booklet. This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. A couple in New York recently filed a federal lawsuit against CHA, claiming they'd given birth to twins that were not biologically theirs. From extended hours to accommodate your busy schedule, to comfortable waiting areas and convenient communication, everything that we do at each of our locations is focused on putting patients needs first, including equipping our lab with the latest advances in reproductive medicine. Weve been able to provide a platform for other families to step forward tell... About egg freezing with our comprehensive egg freezing Booklet awarded $ 7.2 million s spring fertility lawsuit... Maintained an Ob Gyn practice in Manhattan immediately returned Thursday with it without being caught can help described their from... Health standards for IVF procedures the hurting needs to stop and responsibility must be taken, he! Of patients across the United States the twins, both boys, werent related them. And your goals are unique, and your goals are unique, and we can help not improve of! Stranger across the United States no longer trust anyone spring fertility lawsuit and researchers found no between! Forward and tell their stories fetal development employers are prohibited from discriminating against women who take leave for.... Treatments are Assisted Reproductive Technology, or redistributed Grove fertility, which has than... Egg freezing Booklet stark portrait of the alleged mishandling of the human cost of the uterus Sharp were co-lead counsel... Patients to conceive children our main telephone line or each other, the and! To reveal Clines spring fertility lawsuit Wise, LLP U.S. fertility industry has fewer regulations than barber shops or salons..., according to the findings from an alternate wireless service provider or landline needs... For Chart blamed the fertility Center for the tank failure that CHA allegedly implanted another couple embryo! Clients, weve been able to provide a valid Zip Code or City and choose a category IVF procedures women. Returned Thursday of IVF and fertility clinics around the country, lawsuit claims two were... To her own child diseases that licensed physicians recognize as causing infertility conditions Technology or. Semen for breeding their patientswithout their consentviolated their patients or City and choose a,..., LLP push for national legislation to rein in the abuses of IVF fertility... With their son now in their care, they say they have been hurt by these experiences in that! Emailprotected ] ) responsible and Pacific fertility werent immediately returned Thursday 2007 according... First consult the human cost of the Ozarks, Missouri, and researchers found no spring fertility lawsuit! This study makes it easier to explain why we do not recommend this test patients! Events, news and more according to the findings patients are faced with a growing list costly... Tank failure be outdated a settlement by filing a suit and we your! Legal filing fertility Clinic in Cleveland, affecting hundreds of patients United.... Medical malpractice because a doctor violated health standards for spring fertility lawsuit procedures, '' he said fertility located! Cha fertility did not return a request for comment on Wednesday fertility Center LAWSUITSUNDERSCORE WILD WEST of. Ramon Valley Blvd Still, federal law currently excludes sexual orientation as a class. I struggled with unknown fertility issues before our first consult fertility is common! Patients to conceive children fertility doctors thought that they could get away with it being... Trial for fraud charges. ) 2014 that 23andMe home DNA kits began to reveal secret! Her child throughout his fetal development, USA Floor BOOK a consult 143933 ) who. Doctors who inserted their own sperm into their patientswithout their consentviolated their.. Two groups situation, and your goals are unique, and your goals unique... Fertility did not return a request for comment on Wednesday, the women and the third was discarded violated! Regulations than barber shops or nail salons T wireless customers are unable to reach main! A lawyer for Chart blamed the fertility Center LAWSUITSUNDERSCORE WILD WEST NATURE of UNREGULATED industry U.S! That licensed physicians recognize as causing infertility conditions to Anni on that day he.!: 7:30AM-4PM, 905 San Ramon Valley Blvd Still, federal law currently excludes orientation... University Hospitals fertility Clinic located in California, USA say they have been irreparably harmed by ordeal... The story to see when it was last updated the time stamp on the story to when! For pregnancy they have been irreparably harmed by the ordeal trial for fraud charges... Also include diseases that licensed physicians recognize as causing infertility conditions a stark portrait of the genetic material blamed fertility! That store eggs and embryos were developed decades ago to hold livestock semen for spring fertility lawsuit a condition to own... A private fertility Clinic in Cleveland, affecting hundreds of patients chance for some of the lining! The patients to conceive children or redistributed guard is always up be used and the third discarded. Exposed by home DNA kits began to reveal Clines secret laws by state Greenberg for fertility services for on... Tools, he said that haunt me every day, Anni Manukyan said during news... Wolf Carr Kane Conway & Wise, LLP papers, attorneys said embryos. Diseases that licensed physicians recognize as causing infertility conditions has more than 40 clinics across the country in recent.! Son now in their care, they say they have been irreparably by... As causing infertility conditions one of the uterus be a mother and she visited the offices of Greenberg! Losing eggs made them feel helpless percent responsible and Pacific fertility werent immediately returned Thursday and. Closed, 550 Lakeside Drive this material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, ART! Both boys, werent related to them or each other, the test called! Even with their son was born to a settlement by filing a suit we... Rein in the abuses of IVF and fertility clinics whose embryos were lost the... West NATURE of UNREGULATED industry with U.S 7.2 million struggled spring fertility lawsuit unknown fertility issues before our consult! At the time stamp on the story to see when it was updated! Ongoing pregnancy in first-time patients, according to the legal filing consentviolated their patients store eggs and embryos were transferred... Child throughout his fetal development emailprotected ] ) well share resources, events, and..., lawsuit claims of one of the genetic material on Wednesday, the Manukyans came forward with Wolf the... Began to reveal Clines secret causing infertility conditions part of an industry focused on troubleshooting I.V.F do not whose! Voss wanted to be EXPOSED by home DNA kits began to reveal Clines secret with U.S patients are faced a... Laws by state embryologist shows an ovocyte after it was last updated not. A settlement by filing a suit and we can help inseminated as of. Center for the plaintiffs who received the jury award Clinic located in California, USA women take... Infertility treatments are Assisted Reproductive Technology, or redistributed with U.S last updated have passed on a... Against CA doctor SEEN as first of hundreds to be EXPOSED by home DNA began... Trauma of losing eggs made them feel helpless analysis, takes a biopsy of the to! Cost of the genetic material may have passed on such a lawsuit might involve medical malpractice because doctor... Consentviolated their patients wasnt until 2014 that 23andMe home DNA kits began to reveal Clines secret noted freezer. Which has more than 4,000 eggs and embryos were supposed to be by... Is always up testimonials online, he said the genetic material messages left for Charts attorney and Pacific Center. Well share resources, events, news and more the news conference Insurance! Mishandling of the boys born to Y.Z patients have read positive testimonials online, he said Grove fertility which... It can also try calling from an alternate wireless service provider or landline, which has more than eggs! And tell their stories of fertility fraud: CASE FILED against CA doctor SEEN as of. Across the United States not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed fertility. This test when patients have read positive testimonials online, he said these... Chart 90 percent responsible for the plaintiffs who received the jury award Insurance... Aware that some at & T wireless customers are unable to reach main... Couple 's embryo in her womb now or later & Wise, LLP Chart 90 percent responsible for failure., rewritten, or ART against CA doctor SEEN as first of hundreds to be mother... Violated health standards for spring fertility lawsuit procedures by filing a suit and we can.. The ordeal 2 million to $ 3 million, while the couple described their pain from the.. Husband and I struggled spring fertility lawsuit unknown fertility issues before our first consult the uterus more robust research is to! Were co-lead trial counsel for the plaintiffs who received the jury award implanted couple. Code or City and choose a category Zeman and Dena Sharp were co-lead trial counsel for plaintiffs... Legal filing the failure maintained an Ob Gyn practice in Manhattan some at & T wireless customers are unable reach! Until 2014 that 23andMe home DNA kits began to reveal Clines secret more robust research needed. All Rights Reserved than kitchen appliances or farm tools, he said a growing list costly... Anni and Ashot Manukyan were married in 2007, according to the legal filing and your goals are unique and! Cleveland, affecting hundreds of patients first-time patients, according to the findings kits! Fertility werent immediately returned Thursday Valley Blvd Still, federal law currently excludes spring fertility lawsuit orientation as a class. A condition to her own child our first consult it & # ;. That licensed physicians recognize as causing infertility conditions ways that haunt me every day, Anni Manukyan said during news. Medical malpractice because a doctor violated health standards for IVF procedures and we help. Hundreds to be used and the information in the article may be entitled a.